Subscribe
The Host
Erin McGathy is a comedian and artist living in Los Angeles, California. You can see her perform live at the Upright Citizen’s Brigade Theatre, iO West and at parties (unsolicited). She is also a working artist who will paint you anything you’d like for a small fee. She smells like mint, lavender and construction paper. www.erinmcgathy.com
elsewhere
Share the Show!
42 – Genevieve Pearson…
King Of The Nerds star and writer Genevieve Pearson shares with Erin her relationship woes and tactics in college how to pick up guys!
http://www.genevievepearson.c…
41 – Chris Kelly…
SNL writer and long time friend of Erin McGathy, Chris Kelly, tells tales of trying to speed date and reminisces with Erin of what their time together in high school was l…
Dates With Dustin #4: The Renaissan…
Hear ye, hear ye! The This Feels Terrible miniseries where the shows Producer goes on 3 blind dates is back! Date 2 features a fair maiden named Kate and the two go to a Ren F…
Dates With Dustin #3: Caroline/Gend…
The time has come, the first of three dates that Producer and emotional midget Dustin Marshall must go on has arrived! Meet Caroline, an outgoing law student looking fo…
40 – Erin Gibson…
Erin Gibson (@Gibblertron), co-host of the Throwing Shade Podcast, joins Erin and opens up about her divorce. Later on, improv and DJ Lubel! What’s not to love?…
Dates With Dustin #2: Meet The Date…
In this six part This Feels Terrible miniseries, the show’s Producer( who is notoriously inept at dating), goes on dates with three women. In episode two we meet…
39 – Matt Gourley…
Prolific improviser and creator of the legendary SuperEgo podcast, Matt Gourley joins us. He opens up about his current relationship and at the end of the episode, imp…
Dates With Dustin #1…
In a six part miniseries, the producer of This Feels Terrible (a notorious dating failure) goes on 3 blind dates with 3 different women and the entire thing is documente…
38 – Anthony Atamanuik…
Muppet Babies, heroin, prostitutes, molestation, death, dreams, Mr. Belding and a lot of laughs, writer and performer Anthony Atamanuik brings the most gripping Th…
37 – Marc Maron…
The inspiration behind This Feels Terrible: The Podcast and the biggest champion of the medium Marc Maron joins This Feels Terrible for a telling interview on his rela…
36 – Yvette Nicole Brown…
Community star Yvette Nicole Brown comes on This Feels Terrible to talk about her faith, love, why she has chosen celibacy before marriage and shares with us her theory…
35 – DC Pierson…
Writer and comedian DC Pierson regales us with his first story of infatuation and Erin presents some new segments! Plus, listener mail!…
34 – Elizabeth Laime…
Prolific podcaster Elizabeth Laime explains what a frosty is to Erin after telling a nightmarish dating story from her youth and they both top it off with some fan e-mai…
33 – Lindsay Katai, A Girl-Ta…
Happy Valentines Day 2013! Brace yourself for tales of relationship pain. Or seek comfort in others. Comedian and performer Lindsay Katai joins Erin McGathy, regale…
32 – Live From SF Sketchfest …
In the wake of the Harmoncountry tour Erin McGathy traveled across the country for, we present this live This Feels Terrible from the Punchline in San Francisco! Erin t…
31 – Dan Harmon II…
Dan Harmon returns to This Feels Terrible for a special recording from the Harmontown tour. Interrupting Erin and Dan trying to rest in bed, they answer e-mails and tal…
30 – Spencer of Harmontown!…
A special broadcast for the 30th episode of This Feels Terrible! Erin is on the road with the Harmontown podcast tour and from the back of the bus sits with the highly ente…
29 – Duncan Trussell…
The great and knowing Duncan Trussell talks to Erin and mostly helps her cope with her new hair extensions.…
28 – Pete Holmes…
“You Made It Weird” host Pete Holmes and Erin McGathy have a lengthy discussion on sex.…
27 – Mel Stephens…
Vomit On The Web host Mel Stephens meets Erin McGathy for the first time and the two quickly become kindred spirits, with a lot of self-discovery and stay tuned at the end…
26 – Kimber Hall…
Last week we learned about the manic pixie dream girl, this week we actually speak to one and get some insight on what makes her tick. Erin’s friend Kimber Hall sha…
25 – Brendan Hunt…
Writer and performer Brendan Hunt tells us the tales of his Manic Pixie Dream Girl.…
24 – Molly Prather…
Erin McGathy has met her contemporary! Molly Prather brings the dating pain and then some.…
23 – Derek Miller…
Of TBS’s ‘The Wedding Band’ Derek Miller brings a giant notebook and a whole lot of heart to this sit down with the world’s worst relationshi…
22 – Howard Kremer…
Comedian and musician Howard Kremer opens up about the longest break up and how he is with women and plays a game with Erin.…
21 – Mimi Pond & Wayne W…
From the documentary ‘Beauty Is Embarrassing’, Mimi Pond and her husband Wayne White talk about their prolific art, marriage, children and Wayne̵…
20 – Emily Gordon…
Co-host of The Indoor Kids podcast and Producer of the Nerdmelt theater Emily Gordon joins us and brings the most exquisite episode of This Feels Terrible to date!…
19 – Steve Agee…
Welcome to the first annual hangover episode! i.e, Erin got drunk last night. Steve Agee joins Erin and really opens up, offering us the POV of someone who’s had t…
18 – Danny Tamberelli…
From The Adventures of Pete & Pete to This Feels Terrible with Erin McGathy, Danny Tamborelli otherwise known as Little Pete is here to fill you in on his sexual esc…
17 – Judith Shelton…
Eccentric and endearing comedian Judith Shelton gives us our best episode to date! Dating, porn, growing up on a nudist colony; sex and relationships have never sound…
16 – Jon Daly…
Comedian, MC and all around dope dude Jon Daly brings some relationship troubles to the table. Later on, Erin and Jon bond on something and the podcast takes an in depth d…
15 – Casey Wilson…
Happy Endings star Casey Wilson offers us an open and honest look into her love life and Erin talks about being a nanny.
SNL's Casey Wilson Reads Internet Comments…
14 – Charley Koontz…
Community star and the charming Charlie Koontz visits This Feels Terrible and robots are sexualized plus Charlie has one terrible dating story for you.…
13 – Colin Hanks…
Actor Colin Hanks visits This Feels Terrible! Learn about his “white tiger”, married life and Colintology. Erin supplies the charm and ties it off with a…
12 – Rob Schrab & Kate F…
We have our first couple on This Feels Terrible and a married one at that! SCUD author and Channel 101 co-creator Rob Schrab along with actress and comedian Kate Freund t…
11 – Nick Thorburn…
One of Erin’s all time musical idols joins This Feels Terrible! Nick Thorburn (Islands, Unicorns) brings some of his unique charm and we juxtapose terrible dat…
10 – Natasha Vargas-Cooper…
Writer, Story Teller, Trent Reznor obsessive Natasha Vargas-Cooper and Erin McGathy are the dueling pianos of terrible dating stories. Donate to the podcast for a sp…
9 – Fred Stoller…
Stand-up comedian and actor Fred Stoller (Everyone Loves Raymond) graces us with his charming neurotic tales of dating the woman from the Van Halen “Hot For Tea…
8 – Amanda Lund, Terrible Pot…
Erin changes up the pace and brings us face to face with her first heart break story, an interview with actress and friend Amanda Lund who brings a Bill Murray story to the…
7 – Dave Holmes…
The charming and talented Dave Holmes visits This Feels Terrible for a compelling story on growing up in an all boys school and coming out of the closet while Erin takes a…
6 – Dave Horwitz…
The funny and endearing Dave Horwitz stops by for an extra silly This Feels Terrible with an unbelievable stalker story and Erin utters the phrase “I’m th…
5 – Gillian Jacobs…
Gillian Jacobs (Community) joins Erin McGathy on “This Feels Terrible” and brings some awkward tales of dating, growing up an only child, wearing clogs…
4 – Jeff Davis…
On an explicit and adventurous This Feels Terrible with Erin McGathy, one of America’s final bachelors Jeff Davis (Whose Line Is It Anyway?, Harmontown) share…
3 – Derek Waters…
Derek Waters, the creator of Drunk History and an endlessly funny human being, joins Erin McGathy in her weekly celebration of everything terrible about relationshi…
2 – Dave Hill…
Erin McGathy is back with her second episode of “This Feels Terrible” with comedian/musician and AUTHOR Dave Hill. Dave tells a story about myspace dati…
1 – Dan Harmon…
On the premiere episode of “This Feels Terrible”, host Erin McGathy sits down with her boyfriend and the creator of Community, Dan Harmon, to discuss eve…